PAST COMMODORES
| Year | Commodore | Year | Commodore | Year | Commodore |
| 1939 | Reid A. Dunn | 1973 | Frederick P. Warne | 2009 | R. Noel Clinard |
| 1940 | Reid A. Dunn | 1974 | Hiram T. Pritchard, Jr. | 2010 | C. Mayo Tabb, Jr. |
| 1941 | Reid A. Dunn | 1975 | Joseph L. Dennison, Jr. | 2011 | David S. Hinckle |
| 1942 | J. Rucker Ryland | 1976 | James G. Reid, Jr. | 2012 | Alexander Alvis, III |
| 1942 | Henry E. Hutcheson, Jr. | 1977 | Brenton S. Halsey | 2013 | George W. Burke, III |
| 1943 | Henry E. Hutcheson, Jr. | 1978 | Matthew T. Blackwood | 2014 | John B. Wake, Jr. |
| 1944 | Henry E. Hutcheson, Jr. | 1979 | Richard F. Rhodemyre, Jr. | 2015 | Matthew J. Braun |
| 1944 | H. Day Lowry | 1980 | Allen B. Fine | 2016 | William T. Bennett |
| 1945 | H. Day Lowry | 1981 | Clyde N. Gauldin | 2017 | David Lennarz |
| 1946 | James H. Scott | 1982 | Beverley L. Crump | 2018 | Robert P. Whittemore |
| 1947 | J. Rucker Ryland | 1983 | James E. Rogers | 2019 | Paul E. Wash |
| 1948 | J. Marshall Moseley | 1984 | Ian G. Lorimer | 2020 | William H. Schwarzschild, III |
| 1949 | Patrick A. Gibson | 1985 | Wayland W. Rennie | 2021 | Elizabeth P. Staas |
| 1950 | Patrick A. Gibson | 1986 | John R. Hawksworth | 2022 | Joseph W. Roos |
| 1951 | Allan McCullough | 1987 | William A. Perkins, Jr. | 2023 | Dr. Mark G. Wensell |
| 1952 | Jean Y. Ray | 1988 | F. Case Whittemore | ||
| 1953 | Jean Y. Ray | 1989 | Harrison Hubard, Jr. | ||
| 1954 | Jean Y. Ray | 1990 | Robert R. Rock | ||
| 1955 | W.M. F. Bayliss | 1991 | James F. Lipscomb, Jr. | ||
| 1956 | Herbert L. Potts | 1992 | R. Russell Collins | ||
| 1957 | Allan Hicks | 1993 | G. Waddy Garrett | ||
| 1958 | Allan Hicks | 1994 | William C. Spencer, II | ||
| 1959 | Peter Roughton | 1995 | Lydia J. Strickland | ||
| 1960 | Peter Roughton | 1996 | David R. Lee | ||
| 1961 | Howard McCue, Jr. | 1997 | James O. Cobb | ||
| 1962 | Henry A. Converse, III | 1998 | Robert C. Wardwell | ||
| 1963 | John C. Hoggan | 1999 | Judith G. Buis | ||
| 1964 | Harrison Hubard, Sr. | 2000 | Michael W. Karn | ||
| 1965 | Raymond M. Munsch | 2001 | R. Strother Scott | ||
| 1966 | Charles B. Raynor | 2002 | R. Strother Scott | ||
| 1967 | W. Harry Schwarzschild, Jr. | 2003 | Sherard D. Cole, Jr. | ||
| 1968 | Fred L. Williams, Jr. | 2004 | David Hazlehurst | ||
| 1969 | Frank D. Hargrove | 2005 | John M. Buhl, III | ||
| 1970 | William M. Harris | 2006 | Lud H. Kimbrough, III | ||
| 1971 | Allen R. Potts | 2007 | Allan M. Heyward, Jr. | ||
| 1972 | Mason Smith | 2008 | Richard A. Bauer, Jr. |